Assault
& Battery Seth
Rogen comedy is all risk, no reward by
Jason Blair
OBSERVE
AND REPORT: Written and directed by Jody Hill. Cinematography, Tim
Orr. Music, Joseph Stephens. Starring Seth Rogen, Anna Faris, Celia
Weston, Michael Peña, Collette Wolfe and Ray Liotta. Warner Bros.,
2009. R. 86 minutes.
Michael
Peña, Jesse Plemons and Seth Rogen in Observe and Report
Observe and Report commences with mall employees assembling
their wares to The Band’s version of “When I Paint My Masterpiece,”
the jangly gem of wishful thinking gently underscoring their despair.
The unexpected music, sweetly ironic, is only a setup for the next
scene, in which a flasher runs across the parking lot, baring his
bishop to as many people as possible. So far, so strange, so good,
right? Alas, no. We’re quickly entrusted to the man-child responsible
for mall security, Ronnie (Seth Rogen), a high-spirited, dim-witted
mall cop given to lecturing staff on law enforcement and coffee.
Ronnie turns out to be agile for his size, a quality he’ll need
to catch the streaker; mentally, however, he’s runtish, especially
when compared to an actual cop like Harrison (Ray Liotta), the detective
assigned to the case. When the streaker strikes at Brandi (Anna
Faris), the cosmetics girl Ronnie fancies, it sets up an escalating
battle between the two men for Brandi, pulling the film apart in
tone, story and just plain coherence. From there the film darkens
until it simply dims out.
On his small but devoted staff Ronnie places a gag order, insisting
“I’m in charge of this case.” Naturally, he isn’t. A hateful, angry
tirade by Harrison inspires Ronnie to apply for the police force,
an application summarily rejected on psychological grounds. Feeling
defeated, Ronnie embraces his destructive side — spying on changing
rooms, beating up teenagers and using Taser guns without provocation
— and Observe and Report completely loses its way. Lisps,
gays, the disabled: No perceived weakness is safe. At one point
I felt I was experiencing a documentary of schizophrenic felons
in stolen rent-a-cop garb. I don’t watch Rogen and his ilk for lessons
in morality, but Observe and Report is so debased, so unredeemably
unfunny, that it made me feel a little sick to my stomach. It’s
so coldhearted it makes wreckage like Dodgeball seem positively
inspirational.
Observe and Report is redeemed by its two female performers,
Faris and Celia Weston. Faris won’t get much credit for playing
Brandi. For one thing, Brandi essentially is date raped by Ronnie
— a travesty only barely avoided when, seemingly without waking
up, she cajoles Ronnie not to stop. But Faris does nothing halfway
here; she plays the bimbo with abandon, a girl whose mind and morals
are on permanent vacation, which is never as easy as it looks. This
is Faris’s best work since her small but similarly shallow part
as a model in Lost in Translation. Likewise, Celia Weston
is slumming here as Ronnie’s alcoholic mother, but she brings humor,
vulnerability and even grace to the role. Her character is so tattered,
such a bullseye of failure, that Weston embraces her flaws by hiding
them in plain sight. She passes out in the middle of conversations
with Ronnie. Or she merely drifts away in her attention to him,
only to drift back with “I’m drunk” — an apology uttered with all
the fanfare we might use to say “I’m tired” or “I’m thirsty.”
Observe and Report has two modes: boring and offensive.
It is vengeful, stupid and messianic in the worst way: What we have
in Ronnie is a watered-down God complex that’s really an adolescent
gun complex. The film is beyond stupid; it’s stupefying how stupid
it manages to be. I expect more from Jody Hill, the writer of the
HBO cult hit Eastbound and Down, who takes a perfect premise
here and, after a terrific setup, observes little and reports even
less of interest. Hill claims Observe and Report was inspired
by Taxi Driver, a likeness not apparent in this dunderheaded
mess and an indicator that perhaps
Ronnie’s delusions have an autobiographical source.