Imagining
Your Past Atom
Egoyan's latest is smart but distant by
Molly Templeton
Atom Egoyan’s latest film Adoration is, to paraphrase a
line from the film’s chorus of video-chatting talking heads, about
how once you imagine something, it becomes a thing you need to deal
with, whether it’s real or fictional. Simon (Devon Bostick) has
been dealing with a story about his father that his dying grandfather
told him — a story that put a new spin on Simon’s parents’ death
some years ago. Then, in French class, Simon’s teacher, Sabine (Arsinée
Khanjian), reads aloud an article that strikes a chord with Simon.
It’s a story about a terrorist incident — a story in which Simon,
suddenly, sees himself. The resulting piece he writes spreads through
his class and his community, starting everyone talking about why
people make decisions and what they mean, what kind of people they
are. The repercussions of Sabine’s encouragement slip into the film
gradually, as does her investment in Simon’s life. As Simon, Bostick
is a solemn, convincing storyteller, and Scott Speedman gives a
surprisingly affecting performance as the uncle who’s taken care
of Simon since his parents died. Everyone plays their parts well,
but they still feel like parts in an intellectual exercise: What
happens when Simon’s imagining of one years-past incident infects
his community, and they all imagine the same thing, finding their
reactions stronger or stranger than they expected? How does imagining
what we would do in a drastic scenario shape how we feel about such
events? And how is it that people, despite the strange things they
do to each other, can wind up connecting? Adoration is there
to make you think more than feel; it’s a well-made film, but one
that feels like an assignment more than an inspiration.